Abstract
Sand casting makes it difficult to manufacture a fine bar plate for low intensity refining. This study introduced a novel technology for manufacturing lightweight fine bar plates and compared the effects to traditional bar plates. The lightweight fine bar plate base was manufactured using a lightweight aluminum alloy and stainless-steel. Because the bars were inserted into the plate vertically without the draft angle, the stock throughput was improved by approximately 27% compared to the sand-casted bar plates. Additionally, the lightweight fine bar plate maximized internal and external fibrillation while minimizing fiber length loss. In conclusion, the lightweight fine bar plate was shown to be more effective in improving the strength properties of paper and reducing energy consumption.
Download PDF
Full Article
New Technology for Developing a Lightweight Refiner Plate for Hardwood Kraft Pulp Fibers
Byeong-Geol Min,a Ji-Young Lee,b Chul-Hwan Kim,b,* See-Han Park,c Min-Seok Lee,d Ho-Gyeong Gu,d and Chang-Young Lee d
Sand casting makes it difficult to manufacture a fine bar plate for low intensity refining. This study introduced a novel technology for manufacturing lightweight fine bar plates and compared the effects to traditional bar plates. The lightweight fine bar plate base was manufactured using a lightweight aluminum alloy and stainless-steel. Because the bars were inserted into the plate vertically without the draft angle, the stock throughput was improved by approximately 27% compared to the sand-casted bar plates. Additionally, the lightweight fine bar plate maximized internal and external fibrillation while minimizing fiber length loss. In conclusion, the lightweight fine bar plate was shown to be more effective in improving the strength properties of paper and reducing energy consumption.
Keywords: Hardwood pulp; Cutting edge length; Lightweight fine bar; Refining; Draft angle
Contact information: a: Representative director, KOS1 Inc., Gimhae, Korea; b: Professor, Department of Environmental Material Science, IALS, Gyeonsang National University, Jinju, Korea 52828, c: Advisory Professor, Major of Pulp & Paper Chemical Engineering, Gyeongsang National University, Jinju, Korea 52828; d: Graduate students, Dept. of Forest Products, Gyeongsang National University, Jinju, Korea 52828; *Corresponding author: jameskim@gnu.ac.kr
INTRODUCTION
The refining process is considered to be the heart of the papermaking process because it affects the paper machines’ runnability and paper properties. Most companies that manufacture refiner plates are greatly interested in producing fine or ultra-fine bar plates. Refiner plates with fine bar patterns enable low intensity or ultra-low intensity refining. Nissan (1977) suggested that the theoretical maximum intensity limit for modifying hardwood fibers was 5.4 kJ/kg·impact (Nissan 1977). When this was applied to Kerekes’ model (Kerekes 1990), the refining intensity was equal to 0.1 Ws/m. Baker (1995) recommended that the typical SEL (specific edge load) values for chemical pulp should be 2 J/m for softwood and 0.2 J/m for hardwood (Baker 1995). The typical intensity range for hardwood pulps has been generally established to be 0.2 to 0.6 Ws/m (Lumiainen 2000). This means that hardwood pulp fibers with short fiber length and thin fiber walls should be treated with many impacts of small intensity for fibrillation (Kerekes 1990; Ratnieks et al. 2007; Robinson et al. 2010). If refining is not well optimized for hardwood pulps, several negative effects will occur, including greater energy consumption, poor development of core paper properties, severe fiber cutting, and fines generation. Therefore, low or ultra-low intensity refining for hardwood pulp is desirable to achieve greater bulk and opacity at a given sheet strength.
Before fine bar plates were developed, the lowest specific edge loads (SEL) targeted were 0.6 to 0.8 Ws/m, due to limitations of the manufacturing technology. However, as new technologies for fine bar production began to be introduced, low intensity refining of 0.1 to 0.5 Ws/m started to become available without affecting the hydraulic capacity.
The most used technology for manufacturing refiner plates is the original sand casting technology. This technology must give a draft angle of 3 to 5° to protect the patterns in the manufacturing process, thereby limiting the hydraulic capacity on low intensity pattern designs (J&L Fiber Services 2006; Lee et al. 2019). A lost-wax casting technology could be used to manufacture bar plates with no draft angle (Lee et al. 2019). However, it is not easy to reduce the plate weight because there are limitations to the selection of the metal alloy to be used (J&L Fiber Services 2006). Aikawa developed fine bar plates by fabricating and brazing the bars to the plate base to remove the draft angle from the bar shape. This manufacturing process contributed to the creation of refiner plates with narrow bars and deep grooves, but there were limitations in the selection of alloy materials, changes in pattern design, and weight reduction of plates. Another problem with Aikawa products came from the heavy weight of each bar segment. Aikawa Fiber Technology (AFT) confirmed that reducing the active refining diameter greatly helped to save energy because the no-load power increased exponentially with the diameter of the plate (Ratnieks et al. 2007; Robinson et al. 2010; Müller 2016; AFT catalog 2017). The reduction in the diameter of the plate is also related to the reduction in the plate weight. That is, it can serve as an empirical example to show that when the weight of the plate is reduced, it is effective to reduce the initial rotation energy required for rotating the plate. Andritz developed a Durabond manufacturing technology that precisely cuts stainless steel bars with a laser, inserts them into a laser-cut slot formed on a base plate, and then joins them with a proprietary bonding agent. Andritz introduced a multi-segment design concept for the larger size plate over 26 (Müller 2016). Because several Durabond light segments are mounted and fixed to the base plate over the specified diameter, many screw holes are formed on the segments, which can reduce the refining efficiency. In addition, the segment itself is light, but the total weight of the multi-segments fixed to the base plate is still heavy, and the segments’ compatibility with the base plate must be considered when replacing the segments.
In this study, a technique for manufacturing a lightweight fine-bar plate optimized for hardwood pulp fibers was developed by applying a novel method of joining dissimilar metals. The refining effect of this lightweight fine bar plate was compared to that of a default plate that had been prepared by sand casting. Through promoting the superiority of the lightweight refiner vertical bar plate identified through this study to the paper industry, it was intended to contribute to the reduction of refining energy cost and improvement of product quality.
EXPERIMENTAL
Raw Materials
Hardwood bleached kraft pulp (HwBKP) was supplied from the Moorim Paper Inc. mill in Jinju, Korea. The dimensional characteristics of HwBKP are summarized in Table 1. The HwBKP was torn into small pieces and soaked in distilled water for 4 h before disintegration.
Table 1. Fiber Dimension of HwBKP Used for Refining
Manufacturing Process of the Lightweight Fine-bar Plate
Conventional refiner plates have been manufactured by sand casting, which has required a draft angle of 2 to 5° to successfully remove the sand mold for the pattern design prior to closing and pouring (Fig. 1). The sharp corners of the patterns have led to local structural weaknesses such as shrinkage, cracks, tears, and draws (Kay 2002). Refiner plates with the draft angle are considered to minimize the open area of the stock flow zone between bars, stock throughput, and plate life (J&L Fiber Services 2006; AFT catalog 2017; Lee et al. 2019).
Fig. 1. Draft angle of the sand casting for HwBKP
In contrast, refiner plates with zero-degree draft angles can maximize the area of the stock flow path, plate life, hydraulic capacity, and bar edge sharpness (Ratnieks 2007; Robinson et al. 2010). Nevertheless, it is hardly possible to manufacture refiner plates with a zero-draft angle using existing sand-casting technology.
Fig. 2. Bar shapes inserted into plate bases
To develop bar plates without the draft angle, a new method of inserting bars with holes or wedges cut into a plate base was applied (Fig. 2). To reduce the weight of the plate base, aluminum alloy was used as the main material. As a result, it was expected that the overall weight of the plate could be reduced by about 1/2 compared to the sand-casting plate.
The bars were pre-cut with a laser to the desired dimensions. Heat treatment was performed at approximately 1,100 ℃ to improve the strength of the pre-cut bars. If the stainless-steel bars were not heat-treated, the hardness would decrease during the casting process, causing deformation of the bars during plate use. Hardness of the stainless-steel bars was measured under a load of 150 kg and a loading time of 30 s using the Rockwell hardness tester (DTR-300; Daekyung TECH, Incheon, Korea).
The first step to make a lightweight fine bar plate was to insert the bars into an assembly jig (refer to Step 1 in Fig. 3).
Fig. 3. Manufacturing process of a light bar plate
The top surface of the bar was inserted into the assembly jig so that the bottom surface of the bar faced upward. The flask was placed on the bar-inserted assembly jig and packed with a resin-coated sand (refer to Step 2 in Fig. 3). The resin-coated sand was cured by heating it to a temperature of 200 to 500 °C using a liquefied petroleum gas torch (Samwoo, Goyang, Korea). When the flask holding the cured sand was lifted from the assembly jig, the bottom side of the bar to enter the base of the plate was exposed upward (see Step 3 in Fig. 3). After the flask holding the bars was combined with the other flask corresponding to the plate base, the resin-coated sand contained in the flask was again completely cured using the LPG heat source. When the molten aluminum alloy was carefully poured into the inlet of the clamped flask, the molten metal solution filled the empty spaces between the bars as well as the plate base (see Step 4 in Fig. 3). The molten aluminum alloy poured into the flask entered through the holes in each bar and served to fix them securely so that the bars did not come out of the plate base during refining. After the aluminum alloy was completely cooled, the flask containing the sand was removed to obtain a refiner plate segment. A post-treatment process was performed to control the uniform bar height and remove irregularities in the grooves (Fig. 4). The 3D models and the real image of the lightweight refiner plate without a draft angle are shown in Fig. 5.
Fig. 4. Post-treatment process on the plate segments
Fig. 5. 3D model and real image of the lightweight vertical fine bar plate
Refining Process
The soaked pulp specimens of HwBKP were disintegrated using a Valley beater (Daeil Machinery Co., Daejeon, Korea) without a load at a consistency of 1.57 ± 0.04% for at least 3 to 5 min. When the pulp was properly disintegrated, extra water in the pulp stock was removed to adjust its consistency to around 4 to 5% for refining.
Refining was conducted using the laboratory single disk refiner (KOS1 Co., Gimhae, Korea) with two different plates, namely a general casting plate and the newly developed lightweight fine bar plate, shown in Fig. 6. The pulp stock was consecutively refined to achieve a Canadian freeness of approximately 200 mL which was measured based on ISO 5267-2 (2001) standard.
Fig. 6. Laboratory single disk refiner fitted with a lightweight fine bar plate
Measurement of Pulp and Paper Properties
Mean fiber length and fines contents ( 0.2 mm) were determined using FQA-360 (Optest Equipment Inc., Hawkesbury, Canada). Handsheets for measuring the physical properties of paper were made, conditioned, and tested according to the ISO 5269-1 (2005) standard. The physical properties, including tensile, tear and burst strength, were measured based on ISO 5270 (2012), ISO 1924-1 (1992), and ISO 1974 (2012) standards. Paper bulk was calculated using the basis weight of each sheet and thickness was measured using the L&W caliper test (Micrometer, Kista, Sweden). Water retention value (WRV, g/g) was measured based on the ISO 23714 (2014) standard.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Comparison of Two Different Plates
Refining is a process of mechanically improving the inner and outer structures of pulp fibers to enable them to achieve the final properties of paper or cardboard. Refining is often considered the most important stage in the papermaking process. To evaluate the effects of refining on pulp fibers, specific edge load (SEL), and specific surface load (SSL) should be calculated. ISO/TR 11371 (2013) provides guidelines for laboratory-level refining. Both SEL and SSL were also calculated based on ISO/TR guidelines as follows,
where SEL is the specific edge length (J/m, W•s/m), Ptot is the total load power (kW), P0 is no-load power (kW), n is the rotation speed (rev/s), Zr and Zst are the number of rotor and stator bars, l is the bar length (km), CLF is cutting length factor (km/rev), and CEL is cutting edge length (km/s). Two key parameters are given by Eqs. 2 and 3, as follows,
where SSL is the specific surface load (J/m2), IL is the bar width factor (m), Wr is the rotor bar width (m), Wst is the stator bar width (m), and α is the average intersecting angle (°).
As can be seen in Eq. 1, SEL does not consider stock concentration, bar and groove dimensions, and clearance between bars. In contrast, SSL in Eqs. 2 and 3 is calculated by considering the bar dimension and the intersecting angle of the bars, along with the intensity at the bar edges.
Table 2 compares structural differences between the casting plate, lightweight fine bar plate, SEL, and SSL accordingly. The casting plate had a draft angle of 4°, but the light-weight fine bar plate had a draft angle of 0. The number of bars per segment was 165 for the casting plate and 270 for the lightweight fine bar segment. As the number of bars increased, the CEL became larger, allowing low intensity refining. The CEL of the casting plate was 37 km/s, and the CEL of the lightweight fine bar plate was double this, at 75 km/s.
Therefore, the SEL of the lightweight fine bar plate became lower, which allowed lower intensity refining than the casting plate. The SSL was greatly affected by SEL and bar width. That is, assuming that there are two plates with the same SEL, it is possible to prevent excessive fiber cutting by reducing the energy transmitted onto the fibers using a plate with a wider bar.
Another advantage of the lightweight fine bar plate compared to the casting plate was weight reduction. The weight per segment was approximately 47% lighter compared to the casting plate segment. This can reduce the power required during the initial operation of the refiner and facilitate plate replacement.
Hardness Change by Heat Treatment
The heat treatment of ferrous metals usually consists of annealing, normalizing, hardening, and/or tempering. However, for a plate manufactured using an insertion method of dissimilar metals, the casting process adversely affects the hardness of the metals corresponding to the bars inserted into the base plate (refer to Table 3). If the metal material used in the bar is not heat-treated, as shown in Table 3, the spots (2, 4) inserted into the base are softened in the casting process and the bar hardness is reduced. If the hardness of the bar falls, it can easily bend due to the impact between the rotor and stator during refining, shortening the life of the refiner plate.
In contrast, if the bar is heat-treated before insertion into the plate base, there is no material softening during the casting process, as shown in Table 4. Therefore, insertion of the bars into the plate base must be preceded by heat treatment to prevent deformation of the bars during use.
Table 2. Comparison of Refiner Plate Segments With and Without a Draft Angle for HwBKP