Abstract
Unsupported combustion nitrogen (N2) and flame-retardant helium (He) were used to facilitate laser-cutting of cherry wood, and the effects of process parameters, gas flow, and gas reactivity on the surface quality of thin wood were studied. Using identical processing parameters, the cherry wood was laser-cut with and without the added gases. Through comparing the cutting width, heat affected zone (HAZ), and surface burning conditions under different gas-assistance conditions, the influence of the added gases on the gasification and combustion of cherry wood was analyzed. When N2 gas was used, the cutting width was less than that of laser direct cutting, but the surface of the burning area did not remarkably improve. Under the same conditions, when He gas was added, the burning areas on both sides of the kerf were remarkably reduced and the consistency of kerf was good. This indicated that He gas had good oxygen isolation and flame-retardant effects. The surface of the kerf was observed with a scanning electron microscope, and addition of He gas remarkably improved the burning that occurred when cutting kerf. This study combined gas processing and laser technology, and it provided technical references for reducing post treatment improving the surface quality of laser-processed wood.
Download PDF
Full Article
Processing Technology and Experimental Analysis of Gas-assisted Laser Cut Micro Thin Wood
Qingwei Liu,a,b Chunmei Yang,a,b,* Bo Xue,a,b Qian Miao,a,b and Jiuqing Liu a,*
Unsupported combustion nitrogen (N2) and flame-retardant helium (He) were used to facilitate laser-cutting of cherry wood, and the effects of process parameters, gas flow, and gas reactivity on the surface quality of thin wood were studied. Using identical processing parameters, the cherry wood was laser-cut with and without the added gases. Through comparing the cutting width, heat affected zone (HAZ), and surface burning conditions under different gas-assistance conditions, the influence of the added gases on the gasification and combustion of cherry wood was analyzed. When N2 gas was used, the cutting width was less than that of laser direct cutting, but the surface of the burning area did not remarkably improve. Under the same conditions, when He gas was added, the burning areas on both sides of the kerf were remarkably reduced and the consistency of kerf was good. This indicated that He gas had good oxygen isolation and flame-retardant effects. The surface of the kerf was observed with a scanning electron microscope, and addition of He gas remarkably improved the burning that occurred when cutting kerf. This study combined gas processing and laser technology, and it provided technical references for reducing post treatment improving the surface quality of laser-processed wood.
Keywords: Gas assisted; Laser cutting; Quality of cutting kerf; Micromorphology
Contact information: a: Northeast Forestry University, College of Mechanical and Electrical Engineering, Harbin, 150040, China; b: Forestry and Woodworking Machinery Engineering Technology Center, Northeast Forestry University, Harbin, 150040, China;
* Corresponding author: ycmnefu@126.com; nefujdljq@163.com
INTRODUCTION
Laser processing is a non-contact processing method in which a high-power density laser beam irradiates the workpiece and makes it instantly gasify to facilitate drilling, cutting, welding, and other special processing (Naderi et al. 1999; Hovikorpi et al. 2004; Li et al. 2018). Wood has good laser absorption, but the issue of wood surface burning during processing impedes the application of lasers in wood processing (Martin et al. 2005; Fukuta et al. 2016; Alejandro et al. 2017). At the same time, due to serious carbonization phenomenon, the surface roughness was increased, which affected the physical properties and visual beauty of wood (Gaff et al. 2020).
Gurau and Petru (2018) studied the influence mechanisms of different laser parameters on processing quality and determined the mathematical relationship between wood surface roughness and laser parameters. Eltawahni et al. (2011) proposed a process parameter selection method for medium-density fiberboard (MDF) laser cutting used to determine the influence of various factors on quality indicators.
Barcikowski et al. (2006) described the temperature and heat affected zone (HAZ) of the CO2 laser-cutting process and changed the materials and technological parameters to control the damage width caused by laser cutting. Jiang et al. (2016) analyzed wood surface quality after laser-cutting in relation to changes in laser energy and wood type. Yang et al. (2018) analyzed the influence of the ablative mechanism of wood processed with a nanosecond laser on cutting quality and established a prediction model through multiple linear regression equations.
Several scholars have combined auxiliary technology with laser cutting to reduce the HAZ, inhibit oxidation, and further improve wood quality. Hernandez et al. (2010, 2011) studied the influence of dual gas jet-assisted wood laser cutting and explored the influence of airflow on the finish of the cutting surface. Then, they deeply studied the influence of single and double gas jets on the wood laser-cutting process and compared the influence of different auxiliary gases under different pressures on kerf cutting. Yang et al. (2019) studied the effect of water-jet assisted laser cutting on the width and surface morphology of wood. However, the interaction between laser energy and water produced a large amount of water vapor during water-assisted processing, which resulted in unintended chemical reactions that affected the wood surface quality.
To improve wood processing and reduce the burning damage of the HAZ on the kerf surface, a gas-guided laser processing method is proposed in this paper. This study analyzed the use of He gas and N2 gas for gas-assisted laser cutting and compared the gas-assisted method to traditional laser processing methods. Through a single-factor test method, the influence of the added flame retardant and unsupported combustion gases on laser power, cutting speed, cutting width, and processing quality were analyzed. The feasibility of this technology’s application in cutting surface protection and HAZ reduction is discussed, and guidance on effective practices for the industrial production process is given.
EXPERIMENTAL
Principle of Gas-guided Laser Machining
Due to the physical properties of wood, if the selection of laser-cutting processing parameters is not appropriate, instantaneous complete gasification cannot be achieved and oxidation of the cutting surface will occur at high temperatures (Shen and Zhao 2010; Zhao et al. 2016). Therefore, a pressurized gas must be used for assisted processing. Figure 1 shows the ablative processing system for gas-assisted wood laser processing with inert and unsupported combustion gases. Based on the principle of physical damping, the gas with a certain pressure (P1) and velocity was sprayed around the laser beam, and the static and unpressurized oxygen in the air was extruded from the periphery of the nozzle. The residual concentration did not support combustion and blocked the absorption of oxygen in the high temperature area of the workpiece surface, forming a specific gas isolation layer (Martínez-Conde et al. 2017). The subsequent experiments yielded the expected results. The added gases passed through the laser coaxial nozzle to form an airflow shield over the cutting area. The protection of the added gases greatly reduced residual heat, effectively reduced the HAZ, and kept the temperature in the processing area below wood ignition temperature. These conditions allowed for smaller kerf width, a precise incision, and no surface burning.
Fig. 1. Schematic diagram of gas-guided laser cutting
Materials
This experiment used cherry wood (Prunus serotina) as the raw material, which is a typical hardwood with mild wood properties, a loose fiber gap, and easy processability (Linsheng Machining Factory, Dongguan, China). It had an air-dry density of 0.85 g/m3 and a moisture content of 10%. The samples were obtained after processing, and the size was 100 mm × 80 mm × 0.2 mm (length × width × thickness).
The laser processing systems contained a Nd:YAG (Neodymium Doped Yttrium Aluminum Garnet) laser (Dongjun Laser Co., Ltd., Chengdu, China). The wavelength of the laser was 1064 nm, the pulse width was 20 ns, and the pulse repetition rate ranged from 1 kHz to 10 kHz. The experiment specified 3kHz to be used. A PH-LW06-BLP laser cooling system (Dongluyang Co., Ltd., Shenzhen, China) was used with an optical lens combination system (the focal length of the focusing lens was 100 mm and the focused beam spot size was 0.05 mm).
The added gases were ejected from a coaxial supersonic nozzle (gas pressure was 0.2 MPa and the gas flow rate was 5 L/min). Based on considerations of thermal conductivity, electronegativity, dissociation, and ionization energy, N2 gas and He gas were selected as the shielding gases. The quality of the cut section of the wood before and after gas-assisted protection was examined using a FEI Quanta200 scanning electron microscope (SEM, FEI Instruments, Hillsboro, OR, USA).
Process Method
After placing the sample on the worktable, the laser beam entered the processing area through the feeding system through the reflection and focusing action of the optical system. The added gasses, which were supplied by the coaxial nozzle, were sprayed evenly on the surface of the sample. To ensure accuracy, a vertical fiber direction was used for linear cutting. The effects of laser power and cutting speed on the cutting width and the HAZ of the wood were investigated by group experiments with and without gas assistance. After the experiment was completed, the smoothness and cutting defects of cherry thin wood cut with and without gas assistance were observed by SEM. Table 1 shows the process parameters of the single factor experiment.
Table 1. Process Parameters of Single Factor Experiment
RESULTS AND DICUSSION
Effect of Laser Power and Cutting Speed on Cutting Width of Wood
The process parameters were selected to cut samples of thin cherry wood, and the cutting widths under different laser power levels and cutting speeds were measured by digital microscope, 25 × 10 magnification (Supereyes Science and Technology Co., Ltd., Shenzhen, China). After laser cutting, the kerf edge after appeared slightly serrated. Therefore, the average of multiple measurements was calculated for each group of the kerf during measurement. Figure 2 shows the variation trends of the results.
Figure 2b indicates that when the laser power was P = 60 W and the cutting speed was V = 20 mm/s, the kerf and the HAZ were larger. This result was attributed to the long interaction time between the laser beam and thin wood, which produced excessive heat that could not be absorbed and caused burning. Therefore, the cutting width increased, and the surface was seriously burnt. Figure 2e shows that when the cutting speed increased to V = 50 mm/s, the cutting width decreased, the kerf quality improved notably, and the degree of burning reduced. This was consistent with the shorter interaction time between laser beam and wood. As the accumulation of heat per unit time applied to the wood surface by the laser was reduced, the burning speed of the wood at the kerf was lower than the moving speed of the laser. Therefore, the cutting width decreased accordingly, and the laser even failed to cut through the wood. Figure 2h shows that when the cutting speed was V = 50 mm/s and the laser power was P = 15 W, the kerf and the HAZ were smaller and the edge consistency was better. This was due to a reduction in the heat of the thin wood surface, which reduced gasification and combustion. However, the amount of wood removal was low. Therefore, the cutting width was small and surface burning was minor. Figure 2f shows that when the laser power increased to P = 40 W, the kerf and the HAZ were larger and surface burning increased. This was attributed to an increase in power and the consequent heat accumulation on the surface of the thin wood.
The rapid rise in temperature caused wood gasification to increase the cutting width. Therefore, the cutting width decreased with increased cutting speed and increased with increased laser power.
Fig. 2. (a) Effect of process parameters on cutting width; (b) P = 60 W, V = 20 mm/s; (c) P = 60 W, V = 30 mm/s; (d) P = 60 W, V = 40 mm/s; (e) P = 60 W, V = 50 mm/s; (f) P = 40 W, V = 50 mm/s; (g) P = 25 W, V = 50 mm/s; and (h) P = 15 W, V = 50 mm/s
Effect of Kerf Surface Quality of N2 gas
To improve the kerf quality of laser-cut wood and reduce the burning caused by HAZ, N2 gas-assistance was employed. Due to its inactive chemical properties and lack of combustion-supporting properties, N2 gas can greatly weaken the combustion-supporting effect of oxygen, and it is cheap and easily obtainable. The N2 gas blew off the residue, swept the surface, and cooled the cutting zone but was not directly used for cutting. Because it was the only unsupported combustion gas in contact with the workpiece, N2 could form an effective oxygen isolation protective layer on the processing surface and in the laser path range, which prevented the conditions necessary for wood combustion. Figure 3 shows the effect of cutting parameters on the width and surface quality of the kerf with or without N2 gas-assisted processing.
Figure 3 shows that the wood cutting width with N2 gas-assisted laser cutting was smaller than that of the wood cutting width without nitrogen-assisted cutting, and the degree of burning was reduced in the HAZ. This result was due to the combustible gas and oxygen being diluted with the added N2 gas, which reduced the concentration, slowed the reaction rate, and reduced the release of heat. Burning was avoided because of the inactivity and unsupported combustion chemical characteristics of N2 gas. Due to the quenching mechanism of unsupported combustion gas, the quenching ability of nitrogen was weaker than that of inert gas. Therefore, when N2 gas was added, the kerf edge still was serrated due to incomplete gasification during laser cutting. When the cutting speed was faster, the consistency of the whole cutting section was worse. This was due to the accumulation of heat from laser irradiation failing to reach the temperature required for complete gasification of wood when the cutting speed was higher. In addition, the density of N2 gas was less than that of the air, the injection rate was not high enough, or the pressure was low. Therefore, incomplete combustion occurred with the mixing of air during the working process, and the kerf surface was rough due to the air pressure that blew away the burning wood residue. Using N2 gas as an assistant gas for laser wood cutting did not improve kerf quality, reduce the HAZ, or reduce the occurrence of cauterization. N2 gas assistance was only effective for low speed cutting, and a high concentration was required.
