Abstract
Ornamental trees are being promoted to supplement wood for industrial applications in China. To determine the wood utilization potential of an ornamental tree species, Sorbus alnifolia, this study investigated the radial variation of anatomical characteristics of its wood cross-section. The results showed that S. alnifolia is porous with high cell wall percentage, fiber percentage, and vessel percentage, small fiber and vessel sizes, and low vessel frequency. The transition age between juvenile wood and mature wood is 7 to 11 years for vessels, 12 to 16 years for axial parenchyma, and 18 to 24 years for fibers. Mature wood exhibits a higher percentage of cell walls, thicker fiber walls, and a lower percentage of vessels than juvenile wood. This result implies that wood is easy to dry, has strong permeability, good physical and mechanical properties, and a high fiber yield.
Download PDF
Full Article
Suitability of an Ornamental Tree, Sorbus alnifolia, as a Source of Industrial Wood: Properties and the Juvenile to Mature Transition
Pingping Guo, Xiping Zhao,* Qi Feng, and Xinjing Li
Ornamental trees are being promoted to supplement wood for industrial applications in China. To determine the wood utilization potential of an ornamental tree species, Sorbus alnifolia, this study investigated the radial variation of anatomical characteristics of its wood cross-section. The results showed that S. alnifolia is porous with high cell wall percentage, fiber percentage, and vessel percentage, small fiber and vessel sizes, and low vessel frequency. The transition age between juvenile wood and mature wood is 7 to 11 years for vessels, 12 to 16 years for axial parenchyma, and 18 to 24 years for fibers. Mature wood exhibits a higher percentage of cell walls, thicker fiber walls, and a lower percentage of vessels than juvenile wood. This result implies that wood is easy to dry, has strong permeability, good physical and mechanical properties, and a high fiber yield.
DOI: 10.15376/biores.19.4.8654-8667
Keywords: Sorbus alnifolia; Anatomical characteristics; Juvenile wood; Mature wood
Contact information: College of Horticulture and Plant Protection, Henan University of Science and Technology, 263 Kaiyuan Avenue, Luoyang 471023 P.R. China;
* Corresponding author: zhaoxiping1977@126.com
INTRODUCTION
In China, there are considerable supplies of ornamental tree species. Sorbus alnifolia (Sieb. & Zucc.) K. Koch is a precious ornamental tree species with a beautiful crown shape, smooth bark, highly ornamental golden leaves, and red fruits in autumn (Tang et al. 2019). Sorbus alnifolia is also an important fruit tree species, with rich nutrients and various dietary and health functions in its fruits (Kwon et al. 1994). China is currently developing a large area of fruit orchards and landscape forest utilizing S. alnifolia (Dong et al. 2023). During intensive cultivation, S. alnifolia begins to bear fruit at 15 years of age, and 30 years is the peak period of fruit bearing (Zou and Zou 2006). After the peak fruiting period, its fruit yield decreases year by year. Sorbus alnifolia wood harvested through thinning and renewal has the potential to be used for furniture, construction, and interior decoration. However, due to insufficient understanding of its wood properties, it is less commonly used in industry.
Wood is a heterogeneous material. Heterogeneous properties are the main barrier to wood processing and use in industry (Jozsa and Middleton 1999). Wood is a collection of various cells produced by the division of apical meristem and cambium (Zink-Sharp 2004). For hardwood, the cell types are mainly vessels, fibers, and rays, and some also include axial parenchyma and fiber tracheids, which exhibit the unique ordered arrangement of the tree species. The cylindrical column formed by the apical meristem around the pith in the early stages of tree growth is called juvenile wood, also known as core wood or pith wood (Burdon et al. 2004). It is generally believed that compared to mature wood, juvenile wood has smaller cells with thinner walls and narrower diameters. Mature wood near the bark has large fibers, thick cell walls, and low lumen diameters (Savero et al. 2024). Wood with smaller lumen diameters, thicker fiber walls, and higher fiber cell wall ratios has higher density (Couto et al. 2023) and compressive strength (Chukwunonso et al. 2019). Therefore, the physical and mechanical properties of juvenile wood are worse than those of mature wood, with reduced natural durability and drying quality (Bao et al. 2001). However, Vidaurre et al. (2011) believe that the difference between juvenile and mature wood is not significant in hardwood compared to softwood, and juvenile wood can be used as a substitute for mature wood. Therefore, it is important to master the anatomical characteristics of wood and determine the age at which juvenile wood transforms into mature wood. Investigation of the radial variation pattern of wood properties is beneficial for selection and prediction of wood quality, formulation of logging periods, and improvement of wood processing and utilization (Butterfield 2003).
Juvenile and mature wood can distinguish ring numbers from pith (Zobel and van Buijtenen 1989). In fact, the true reflection of the biological progression from juvenility to maturity is anatomical characteristics that make up wood (Heliñska-Raczkowska and Fabisiak 1999). Liu et al. (2020) reported that the transition between juvenile and mature wood was between 7 and 8 years based on patterns of radial variation in earlywood fiber length. A differentiation of juvenile wood from mature wood is to set a threshold for cell characteristics, which has advantages for addressing product performance. However, the disadvantage of applying single property threshold values for juvenile and mature wood is that they apply only to certain limited product performance attributes. Fos et al. (2023) reported that the transition from juvenile wood to mature wood begins in the 5th year of growth based on radial variation in anatomical characteristics of Paulownia elongata x fortunei hybrid Cotevisa 2 wood. Savero et al. (2024) reported that the clearest transition from juvenile to mature wood in six Korean oak species was observed in radial variation in earlywood vessel diameter and fiber length with maturation ages ranging from 19 to 44 years. In summary, the transition of wood properties from juvenile wood to mature wood is a tree growth pattern, but there are differences in transition patterns among different genera and species.
So far, there have been few studies on the anatomical characteristics of S. alnifolia wood, and research on radial variation and maturation age is also limited. Additional information on the age of maturity is crucial to ensuring wood quality and enhancing the economic value of high-value applications. Therefore, the goals of this study were to: (1) determine anatomical characteristics in the cross-section of S. alnifolia wood; (2) analyze the variation in anatomical characteristics from pith to bark; (3) determine the transitional age between juvenile and adult wood; and (4) compare anatomical characteristics between juvenile and mature wood.
EXPERIMENTAL
Materials
Three S. alnifolia trees were sampled from Longyuwan Forest Farm, located in the hinterland of Funiu Mountain, 165 km southwest of Luoyang City, China. The forest farm is situated between 111 ° 40 ‘-111 ° 50’ E and 33 ° 39 ‘-33 ° 43’ N, with an altitude of 1083 m. In 1997, it was designated as a national nature reserve. The height and diameter at breast height of the sample trees was measured using a Laser Range Finder (2200B, Onick Outdoor Optics Inc., USA) and a measuring tape, respectively. From each sample tree, an increment core was drilled at breast height (1.3 m) in the south direction from bark to pith. Tree age was checked by counting rings from the increment core. The characteristics of the sampled trees are shown in Table 1.
Table 1. Characteristics of the Sampled Sorbus alnifolia Trees in Relation to the Analysis of Radial Variation in Wood Anatomy
Methods in Wood Anatomy
The collected increment cores were softened with ethylenediamine. Then 13-μm-thick transverse sections were cut using a Lycra slicer. The sections were stained with safranin and photographed using a digital imaging system (Mshot-MD50, Microshot Technology Limited, Guangzhou, China). An image computer analysis system (TDY, version 5.2, Beijing Tian Di Yu Technology Co., Ltd., Beijing, China) was used to measure ring-by-ring anatomical features. An average of 60 cells for each tissue type were measured per tree ring. The cell wall percentage was calculated from the cell wall area percentage of all cell types in the cross section microscopic images of each tree ring. The percentage of each cell type was calculated from all cell areas (including wall and lumen) percentage of the type in the cross section of each tree ring.
Data Analysis
Statistical analyses were performed using SPSS (Version 24.0, International Business Machines Corporation, Armonk, NY, USA), including mean, maximum, minimum, standard deviation (SD), and coefficient of variation (CV) of anatomical characteristics. Partial correlation analysis was used to examine the correlation between anatomical characteristics. Two-segmented linear regression models were used to evaluate the transition from juvenile to mature wood, in terms of ring number, for anatomical characteristics. Differences in anatomical characteristics between juvenile and mature wood were studied using variance analysis, and the significance of differences was tested using Duncan’s Multiple Range Test.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Cell Wall Percentage (CP)
The cross-section from pith to bark of S. alnifolia is shown in Fig. 1. The width of tree rings varies greatly. As reported in many species (Bao et al. 2001), early formed wood has a larger ring width than later formed wood. This is related to the period of wood formation, cell size, proportion, and arrangement of different components (Plomion et al. 2001). The CP is the smallest near the pith, then shows an increasing trend from the pith to the bark, especially in the first 10 years where the rate of increase is relatively high (Fig. 2). The CP shows an average value of close to 50% and a maximum of 63.7% (Table 2), which means that mature wood has a high density (Fortunel et al. 2014), and excellent physical-mechanical properties of wood (Akyildiz and Kol 2010).
Fig. 1. Cross section microscopic images of the wood from pith to bark of Sorbus alnifolia
Fig. 2. Observed (mean) and two segment-fitted cell wall percentage (CP) trends vs. annual ring number in the wood of Sorbus alnifolia. Bars show standard error. The green, solid lines represent the first segment (juvenile wood). The red, dashed lines represent the first segment (mature wood).
The segmented regression showed that the transition age from juvenile to mature wood is 11 years for CP. The fitting effect was good for both juvenile and mature wood (Fig. 2). The CP difference between juvenile and mature wood was significant (p = 0.00), with the average value approaching 50% in mature wood and about 40% in juvenile wood (Table 3). A high CP is generally associated with a high fiber percentage (FP) and a low tissue proportion of thin-walled cells, such as a high vessel percentage (VP). There was a significant positive correlation between CP and FP (Table 4). CP was also significantly correlated with axial parenchyma tissue percentage (AP) and axial parenchyma cell double wall thickness (AT). The AP was less than 1% (Table 2). Such results imply that there will be little impact on wood processing and utilization (Zobel and van Buijtenen 1989).
Table 2. Descriptive Statistics in the Cross-section of the Wood Anatomical Characteristics of Sorbus alnifolia
Table 3. Differences in the Cross-section of the Juvenile and Mature Wood Anatomical Characteristics of Sorbus alnifolia
Table 4. Correlation Among the Wood Anatomical Characteristics of Sorbus alnifolia
Fiber
The average FP of S. alnifolia is close to 50% (Table 2), indicating the wood’s potential to achieve high pulse yield (Stokke and Manwiller 1994). However, FP variability is high (CV = 0.54), with a maximum value of 61.5% and a minimum value of only 34.4%. Like CP, FP shows an overall upward trend from pith to bark, but it appears to have decreased slightly in the first 10 years and fluctuated greatly around 46% (Fig. 2A). Segmented regression shows that the transition age from juvenile to mature wood is 11 years for FP. The radial trend of FP is complex with low linear fitting in juvenile wood and good fitting in mature wood (R2 = 0.44). Analysis of variance shows that there was no significant FP difference between juvenile wood and mature wood (p = 0.27, Table 3).
Both fiber wall thickness (FT) and fiber lumen radial diameter (FD) decrease slightly with increasing ring age, and then increase in some years. Segmented regression indicates that the transition age occurred at 24 and 18 years, respectively (Fig. 4 A, B). This means that as the wood matures, fiber size increases with age, but it fluctuates greatly. Similar results were also found in Acacia mangium (Xu et al. 2005). The average FT of S. alnifolia is 2.26 μm, which is close to the FT of the fruit tree species Nephelium iappaceum, but less than Syzygium malaccense and Durio zibethinus (Aiso et al. 2017). Mature wood has a significantly higher FT than juvenile wood (Table 3). Increased FT can improve wood’s mechanical strength, such as compressive strength and flexural strength. At the same time, thicker walls may also affect wood density and texture. Wood with thicker cell walls and wider cell diameters typically exhibits higher quality (Barnett and Jeronimidis 2003).
Fig. 3. Observed (mean) and two segment-fitted tissue percentage trends vs. annual ring number in the wood of Sorbus alnifolia. Bars show standard error. The green, solid lines represent the first segment (juvenile wood). The red, dashed lines represent the first segment (mature wood). AP represents axial parenchyma tissue percentage; FP represents fiber percentage; RP represents ray percentage; VP represents vessel percentage.
Fig. 4. Observed (mean) and two segment-fitted fiber wall thickness (FT) and fiber lumen radial diameter (FD) trends vs. annual ring number in the wood of Sorbus alnifolia. Bars show standard error. The green, solid lines represent the first segment (juvenile wood). The red, dashed lines represent the first segment (mature wood).
Vessel
S. alnifolia wood is porous, with VP ranging from 20.7% to 46.4% (Table 2). The pores are mostly single, and no pore clusters have been observed (Fig. 1). Occasionally pore chains are seen, which is similar to others (Zhang et al. 2006). Distribution, arrangement, size, and number of vessels directly affect wood uniformity and infiltration treatment (Emaminasab et al. 2017), and paper properties (Sari et al. 2012). According to Fig. 3B, VP first increased slightly and then decreased from pith to bark. Segmented regression showed that the transition age was 13 years, and VP of mature wood was significantly lower than that of juvenile wood (p = 0.01, Table 3). However, the linear fit was not good, indicating obvious fluctuations.
Vessels mainly serve as conduits for water transport during tree growth. Sperry (2003) believes that vessel double wall thickness (VT) is related to the strength of the vessel wall, and the wall can provide protection and support for vessels. However, under high tension conditions in the water column, VT resistance to container deformation appears unlikely (Carlquist 2001). From Fig. 5A, it can be observed that the VT variation shows a first decreasing and then slightly increasing trend from pith to bark. Segmented regression indicates that the transition age is 7 years. However, the VT difference between juvenile and mature wood is not significant (Table 2).