Abstract
Corrugated board is a ubiquitous material, playing a critical role in modern packaging, transportation, and storage industries. While traditional flute shapes like sinusoidal waves dominate production, exploring and implementing novel fluting geometries could significantly enhance the mechanical properties of this material. This editorial discusses the theoretical future of various flute shapes and their potential to improve mechanical performances, such as bending stiffness and load-bearing capacity. Embracing innovative design and production techniques could lead to more sustainable and high-performing usages for corrugated cardboard for diverse applications.
Download PDF
Full Article
Exploring the Future of Novel Flute Shapes and Their Mechanical Benefits
Tomasz Garbowski 
Corrugated board is a ubiquitous material, playing a critical role in modern packaging, transportation, and storage industries. While traditional flute shapes like sinusoidal waves dominate production, exploring and implementing novel fluting geometries could significantly enhance the mechanical properties of this material. This editorial discusses the theoretical future of various flute shapes and their potential to improve mechanical performances, such as bending stiffness and load-bearing capacity. Embracing innovative design and production techniques could lead to more sustainable and high-performing usages for corrugated cardboard for diverse applications.
DOI: 10.15376/biores.20.2.2483-2486
Keywords: Sustainable packaging; Corrugated board; Fluting shapes; Mechanical performance; Edge crush resistance; Bending stiffness; Material efficiency; Production innovation
Contact information: University Center for ECO-materials. Poznan University of Life Sciences; email: tomasz.garbowski@up.poznan.pl
The Role of Corrugated Board
Cardboard has established itself as a fundamental material in packaging, providing a versatile, cost-effective solution for transporting goods worldwide. Its strength, resilience, and relatively low weight make it ideal for diverse applications, from bulk shipping to retail-ready packaging. The corrugated layer, or flute, plays a key role in providing these properties by forming a lightweight, rigid structure that resists compressive and bending forces.
The traditional sinusoidal flute shape, widely used for its balance of performance and manufacturability, has limitations (Gaudelas et al. 2023). As global demands evolve, particularly regarding sustainability and performance, the industry faces new challenges (Garbowski and Pośpiech 2024). Packaging material must be lighter, stronger, and more environmentally friendly, with enhanced recyclability and resource efficiency. Addressing these challenges requires rethinking the corrugated layer’s design and exploring new fluting geometries that could offer superior mechanical properties.
This editorial examines the potential of novel flute shapes to improve cardboard’s mechanical behavior, emphasizing their importance in meeting modern requirements (Garbowski and Borecki 2024). By investing in innovative designs, the industry can achieve more efficient, sustainable packaging solutions that outperform traditional products.
Current State of Flute Design
The widespread use of sinusoidal flutes in corrugated cardboard production reflects their effectiveness and compatibility with high-speed manufacturing processes (Luo et al. 2022). This shape offers predictable mechanical properties and cost efficiency, making it the industry standard (Popil 2012; Johst et al. 2023). However, its limitations become evident as market demands for improved performance and sustainability grow. Traditional designs may lack the strength, stiffness, or adaptability required for specific packaging applications (Garbowski 2022).
Exploring alternative flute geometries presents an opportunity to enhance performance. Circular, spline-based, and trapezoidal profiles offer potential improvements in load-bearing capacity, edge crush resistance, and bending stiffness. Circular flutes, for example, distribute compressive stresses more uniformly, reducing the risk of localized deformation. Spline-based shapes provide customizable mechanical behavior, while trapezoidal designs enhance structural rigidity.
Adopting these shapes poses challenges in terms of manufacturing complexity, cost, and scalability. High-speed production lines must adapt, and the economic feasibility of new shapes must be evaluated. Nevertheless, the potential performance gains justify exploring these innovations, especially in light of growing sustainability and efficiency demands.
Exploring Futuristic Fluting Shapes
The sinusoidal flute shape has traditionally defined the corrugated layers in a cardboard’s mechanical performance because of its balance of strength, weight, and cost-effectiveness. It represents only a fraction of the potential designs that could maximize the material’s capabilities. Researchers and engineers are now delving into a diverse range of alternative geometries that aim to unlock new mechanical properties and performance enhancements.
These novel shapes seek to address specific limitations inherent to the sinusoidal profile, such as limited adaptability to varying load conditions and suboptimal distribution of stresses. By modifying the corrugated layer’s profile, these alternative designs strive to improve crucial properties such as edge crush resistance, which is critical for maintaining structural integrity during stacking and transport. This exploration of new geometries holds the promise of transforming corrugated board into a more efficient, resilient, and adaptable material suited for a broad range of modern applications.
Circular fluting
This design departs from traditional sinusoidal waves by using semi-circular segments that connect vertically, offering enhanced load distribution and greater resistance to localized deformation. This improved edge crush performance can benefit applications demanding high stacking strength, though precise forming increases manufacturing complexity. Additionally, the uniform curvature of circular flutes helps in dispersing localized stresses more effectively, which can extend the material’s lifespan in demanding environments.
Variable sinusoidal profiles
By altering wave period and amplitude, variable sinusoidal profiles allow for tailored mechanical responses. Shorter wave periods can enhance stiffness and load capacity, while longer periods offer more flexibility. This adaptability strikes a balance between innovation and compatibility with existing production processes. It also offers a versatile solution for packaging that requires customization for different load conditions without significant retooling.
Spline-based profiles
Spline-based profiles range from triangular to balloon-like shapes, allowing customized mechanical behavior through precise curvature control. This opens doors to new performance characteristics, but achieving consistent production remains challenging due to geometric complexity. Such profiles enable fine-tuning of stress distribution, making them suitable for applications that require both rigidity and shock absorption.
Trapezoidal and rectangular variants
Trapezoidal and rectangular shapes offer higher bending stiffness due to increased moments of inertia, enhancing load-bearing capacity. However, these designs may introduce stress concentrations, requiring careful optimization to balance performance and structural integrity. Their distinct flat faces and sharp corners can be engineered for specific performance improvements in structural applications.
Mechanical advantages and challenges
Each shape offers unique benefits: circular and spline-based profiles enhance edge crush resistance, while variable sinusoidal and trapezoidal designs improve stiffness and load distribution. Despite potential gains, challenges such as manufacturing complexity and cost increases must be addressed. Collaborative efforts among researchers, engineers, and industry stakeholders, coupled with investments in precision forming and rigorous testing, are crucial for success. In summary, exploring these futuristic fluting shapes can enhance corrugated cardboard’s mechanical properties, creating sustainable, high-performance packaging solutions.
Potential Mechanical Benefits
Exploring new fluting shapes offers significant mechanical benefits for corrugated cardboard. Enhanced edge crush resistance improves stacking strength and reduces the risk of deformation under load. Circular and spline-based profiles achieve this by distributing compressive forces more uniformly. Improved bending stiffness, enabled by trapezoidal and rectangular shapes, enhances structural rigidity, allowing for thinner, lighter sheets without compromising performance.
Optimized load distribution is another key benefit. Variable sinusoidal and spline-based profiles can distribute loads more evenly, reducing stress concentrations and increasing the material’s overall resilience. Enhanced energy absorption, critical for protecting goods during impact, is achievable through shapes with smooth transitions, such as circular and spline-based flutes. By reducing material usage through optimized performance, novel shapes contribute to sustainability goals. Thinner, lighter sheets reduce raw material consumption and transportation costs, supporting a more sustainable supply chain. While challenges remain, the potential for improved performance and resource efficiency justifies continued investment in research and development.
Production and Economic Feasibility
Adopting new fluting shapes in corrugated cardboard production requires addressing manufacturing and economic challenges. Traditional high-speed production lines are optimized for sinusoidal flutes, necessitating modifications to accommodate new shapes. Precision control and consistent material behavior are critical for achieving uniform performance across complex geometries.
Economic feasibility is a key consideration, as the packaging industry is highly cost-sensitive. New shapes must offer clear benefits to justify potential increases in production costs. However, these benefits—such as reduced material usage, enhanced performance, and lower transportation costs—can offset initial investments. Scalability and market acceptance are essential for successful adoption.
Solutions include leveraging emerging technologies such as precision forming, digital modeling, and automation. Collaborative efforts among industry stakeholders can drive innovation, develop new standards, and facilitate the adoption of complex designs. By addressing manufacturing and cost challenges, the industry can realize the benefits of novel fluting shapes without compromising efficiency or affordability.
Concluding Thoughts – A Call for Innovation
The exploration of novel fluting shapes represents an opportunity to redefine the mechanical performance and sustainability of corrugated cardboard. By improving edge crush resistance, bending stiffness, and load distribution, these shapes offer the potential for lighter, stronger, and more efficient packaging solutions. Collaborative innovation among researchers, engineers, and industry partners is crucial to overcoming manufacturing challenges and achieving economic feasibility.
Embracing new designs aligns with global demands for sustainability and improved resource efficiency. By fostering a culture of experimentation and investing in research and development, the corrugated cardboard industry can lead the way in creating high-performance, environmentally-friendly packaging solutions. This call for innovation emphasizes the potential to push beyond traditional designs, including Artificial Intelligence (Garbowski 2023), offering transformative advances that meet the evolving needs of society and industry alike.
References Cited
Garbowski, T. (2022). “Digitization of corrugated board,” Polish Paper Review 78(12), 683-686. DOI: 10.15199/54.2022.12.2
Garbowski, T. (2023). “Revolutionizing corrugated board production and optimization with artificial intelligence,” BioResources 19(2), 2003-2006. DOI: 10.15376/biores.19.2.2003-2006
Garbowski, T., and Borecki, P. (2024a). “Analysis of the impact of futuristic corrugated layer shape on mechanical properties and cost of single-wall corrugated board,” Polish Paper Review 80(11), 271-277. DOI: 10.15199/54.2024.11.1
Garbowski, T., and Pośpiech, M. (2024b). “The impact of scientific research on corrugated board on the lifecycle of packaging,” Packaging Review 4, 6-17. DOI: 10.15199/42.2024.4.1
Gaudelas, A., Blanchet, P., Gosselin, L., and Cabral, M. R. (2023). “Physical characterization of biobased corrugated panels, an innovative material,” BioResources 18(3), 5838-5858. DOI: 10.15376/biores.18.3.5838-5858
Johst, P., Kaeppeler, U., Seibert, D., Kucher, M., and Böhm, R. (2023). “Investigation of different cardboard materials under impact loads,” BioResources 18(1), 1933-1947. DOI: 10.15376/biores.18.1.1933-1947
Luo, P., Yang, C., and Wang, T. (2022). “Making ultra-thin high density fiberboard using old corrugated container with kraft lignin,” BioResources 17(2), 2696-2704. DOI: 10.15376/biores.17.2.2696-2704
Popil, R. E. (2012). “Overview of recent studies at IPST on corrugated board edge compression strength: Testing methods and effects of interflute buckling,” BioResources 7(2), 2553-2581.